This is a Hitskin.com skin preview
Install the skin • Return to the skin page
Which should be stronger...State or Federal governments?
+2
IR
Ahmed
6 posters
Page 1 of 1
Which should be stronger...State or Federal governments?
Classical debate. This is about the USA btw.
Ahmed- NH Admin
- Number of posts : 51452
Username Change Points : 61089
Reputation : 147
Registration date : 2007-10-14
Mood :
Country :
Re: Which should be stronger...State or Federal governments?
Um...Federel stronger I guess
IR- NH Pink
- Number of posts : 2940
Username Change Points : 7160
Reputation : 25
Registration date : 2009-08-11
Mood :
Country :
Ahmed- NH Admin
- Number of posts : 51452
Username Change Points : 61089
Reputation : 147
Registration date : 2007-10-14
Mood :
Country :
Re: Which should be stronger...State or Federal governments?
I feel that they should have almost equilibrium, leaning toward federal. This is because of a lesser of two evils situation. With a strong federal gov't, there can be tyranny, but with strong state governments, differences in political preference of the state can cause differences in laws of the states.
Fangy- NH Retired Moderator
- Number of posts : 8314
Username Change Points : 14227
Reputation : 71
Registration date : 2009-03-23
Mood :
Country :
Re: Which should be stronger...State or Federal governments?
Um... federel sound bigger
IR- NH Pink
- Number of posts : 2940
Username Change Points : 7160
Reputation : 25
Registration date : 2009-08-11
Mood :
Country :
Re: Which should be stronger...State or Federal governments?
Fang wrote:I feel that they should have almost equilibrium, leaning toward federal. This is because of a lesser of two evils situation. With a strong federal gov't, there can be tyranny, but with strong state governments, differences in political preference of the state can cause differences in laws of the states.
I don't think that's possible. You would need to have one stronger than the other or both would be weak.
For example: If let's say the Federal gov and state gov make opposing rules...which one overrides the other?
Ahmed- NH Admin
- Number of posts : 51452
Username Change Points : 61089
Reputation : 147
Registration date : 2007-10-14
Mood :
Country :
Re: Which should be stronger...State or Federal governments?
Federal. But it would have to be a checks and balances system like our federal gov't had.
Fangy- NH Retired Moderator
- Number of posts : 8314
Username Change Points : 14227
Reputation : 71
Registration date : 2009-03-23
Mood :
Country :
Re: Which should be stronger...State or Federal governments?
state.
because they are closer to the people they have jurisdiction over.
because they are closer to the people they have jurisdiction over.
Steve- NH Member
- Number of posts : 7323
Username Change Points : 11443
Reputation : 33
Registration date : 2007-11-29
Mood :
Re: Which should be stronger...State or Federal governments?
You mean "has"?
Anyways, I'll be the devil's advocate and say State...like what Jefferson supported.
My argument: The US was created by an agreement by the different states, so you cant undermine their sovereignty.
Anyways, I'll be the devil's advocate and say State...like what Jefferson supported.
My argument: The US was created by an agreement by the different states, so you cant undermine their sovereignty.
Ahmed- NH Admin
- Number of posts : 51452
Username Change Points : 61089
Reputation : 147
Registration date : 2007-10-14
Mood :
Country :
Re: Which should be stronger...State or Federal governments?
I say state, even though in the past there has been many problems with it. I think that the vote of the state should matter more than some dude sitting in a random state.
Craig- NH Member
- Number of posts : 10059
Username Change Points : 19323
Reputation : 82
Registration date : 2009-07-27
Mood :
Country :
Re: Which should be stronger...State or Federal governments?
Federal should be able to overrule anything that state does
IMO
IMO
Doc- NH Member
- Number of posts : 15155
Username Change Points : 15318
Reputation : 133
Registration date : 2007-10-25
Mood :
Country :
Ahmed- NH Admin
- Number of posts : 51452
Username Change Points : 61089
Reputation : 147
Registration date : 2007-10-14
Mood :
Country :
Doc- NH Member
- Number of posts : 15155
Username Change Points : 15318
Reputation : 133
Registration date : 2007-10-25
Mood :
Country :
Re: Which should be stronger...State or Federal governments?
You forgot to add /thread
>_>
>_>
Ahmed- NH Admin
- Number of posts : 51452
Username Change Points : 61089
Reputation : 147
Registration date : 2007-10-14
Mood :
Country :
Doc- NH Member
- Number of posts : 15155
Username Change Points : 15318
Reputation : 133
Registration date : 2007-10-25
Mood :
Country :
Re: Which should be stronger...State or Federal governments?
Anyways...
I say state, because each state is sovereign.
I say state, because each state is sovereign.
Ahmed- NH Admin
- Number of posts : 51452
Username Change Points : 61089
Reputation : 147
Registration date : 2007-10-14
Mood :
Country :
Similar topics
» Federal Government of America Inc. ?
» Which is stronger the pencil or the pen?
» The Sun is Stronger than Planets
» Pakistan, a failed state?
» Not Penn State
» Which is stronger the pencil or the pen?
» The Sun is Stronger than Planets
» Pakistan, a failed state?
» Not Penn State
Page 1 of 1
Permissions in this forum:
You cannot reply to topics in this forum
|
|