I think Flame should lose his GFX rank...I mean, he rarely does any GFX work...

rezev should get the rank >.>

ir has her pink rank, i doubt she wants to lose it so soon.

Ask her

ok, so are you asking a ruling on this or just putting forth a statement.

Flame should be given a chance to respond before any "decision" is made

Well he doesn't look like he'll reply.

just wait. When he sees, may be he will. To be fair, you have to give him a chance to explain

I thought I already replied in the other thread?

I think you have to make the decision

flame has made his reply and seeing as there is no reason to strip his rank shall we declare this closed?

I think yes...Ahmed, as the creator of this topic, do you request it locked?