Well this thread is to discuss everything Harry Potter!

I have a question for those that read the last book, the seveth one:

How in the world did Nevile get the sword from the hat if the goblin took it from Harry Potter at half the book?

didn't harry get it back from the goblin? maybe when they were at the malfoys, i didnt notice any continuity errors.

i was watching a doc the other day and some evangelical christians were saying harry potter is an enemy of God

No, the goblin took it and he disappeared from the story. That is the only continuity error that I found in the story (and series)

Yes I saw them on the news. They say it teaches witchcraft and might start a "Harry Potter" religion or so...

oh i didnt see that, this was about a camp which brain washes kids into being christian

Oh ya, I saw those camps in a documentary. Like the, in America, "Southern Baptist Camp" or so...

there was nothing right about that camp. beliefs don't mean much if your forced to accept them

Agreed :agree:
------------------------
So do you own any HP books?

ive read them all, i think i own a few, the first few were proably bought for me

I own: 1,2,4

Did you think any were boring:

I thought the 1st was boring really.

i dont think so, i was alittle ashamed of having them for a while because they weren't cool until the 4th/5th book

Lol,true enough...(Eventhough I still think the 2nd was cool )

I started out by reading the 2nd book.

i started on the first one, it wasnt bad really, i think each was better than the one before and i got bored at the start of the 4th book

I think the 5th was da best

Who do you guys think is more...err....pash (If that's the right word)

Mr.Barty Crouch or Mr. Scrimgeour

Choose!

do you mean posh? O.o

Yeah....that's what I meant. (I never used the word before )

[quote="Ahmed"]No, the goblin took it and he disappeared from the story. That is the only continuity error that I found in the story (and series)quote]

This is not an error Ahmed. According to old magical rules, the (Gryffindor's )hat is suppose to help a true Gryffindor. It has the power to bring the Sword to the person in need (another relic of Gryffindor). This is why Harry got the sword in the second book and Neville in the seventh.

And I own 1, 2. 4 and 6.

And by the way, what do you mean by posh?

[quote="Hassan I"]

Ahmed wrote:

No, the goblin took it and he disappeared from the story. That is the only continuity error that I found in the story (and series)quote]

This is not an error Ahmed. According to old magical rules, the (Gryffindor's )hat is suppose to help a true Gryffindor. It has the power to bring the Sword to the person in need (another relic of Gryffindor). This is why Harry got the sword in the second book and Neville in the seventh.

And I own 1, 2. 4 and 6.

And by the way, what do you mean by posh?

No...Harry had already taken the sword in the 2nd book. There is alos one sword.

I own those books as well.

By posh, I meant more political like, you know, political people are always so haughty and important...I hope you understand what I mean.

Harry got the sword through the hat in the second book, right Ahmed?

And I think that the late Mr. Crouch Sr. is more posh because it is said that he even sacrificed his son to maintain his status and position.

Hassan I wrote:

Harry got the sword through the hat in the second book, right Ahmed?

And I think that the late Mr. Crouch Sr. is more posh because it is said that he even sacrificed his son to maintain his status and position.

Yes, then the goblin took it from Harry in the 7th book. Then "magicallly" Neville got it out of the hat.

You know...before seeing the picture of Mr.Crouch I imagined him a well built, stern, agressive looking sort of man, wearing a brown tuxedo with black shining shoes.

But in the movies an old looking man acxted his role...

Hassan do you agree with Mr.Crouch's poiint of views?

No, I do not agree with his ideology. I do not think that one should act in such aggresive and brutal ways, as in even deny a trial to presumed death eaters (namely Sirius) to enforce law.

Hmmm...this reminds me of a certain person that is currently in Beijing...except that their is amjor differnce in IQ levels...I hope you undersatdnw aht i eman Hassan

Also you can't deny that he was right when he imprisned his son.

Yeah, he was right. But that shows that even he has emotions.

What shows he has emotions...it was all because of his wife, not him.

He helped his wife and son by changing them and bringing him out of Azkaban.